Article name Clerical-Protective Direction in the Russian Historiography of the Old Believers of the 1850s: the Structure of Historical Research
Authors Madzharov A.S. 1 K. Marksa st., Irkutsk, 664003, Russia,
Bibliographic description Madzharov A. S. Clerical-Protective Direction in the Russian Historiography of the Old Believers of the 1850s: the Structure of Historical Research // Humanitarian Vector. 2021. Vol. 16, No. 3. PP. 24–33. DOI: 10.21209/1996-7853-2021-16-3-24-33.
UDK 271.2-86(470)(091)
DOI 10.21209/1996-7853-2021-16-3-24-33
Article type
Annotation Understanding the historiography of the old believers depends on the level of development of the history of historical science, the development of its categorical apparatus. The lack of clarity of the research structure leads to uncertainty in terminology, in the description of scientific achievements and dead ends. The key historical works (historiographical facts) that defined the face of the science of their time are arbitrarily deleted from the literature, and the directions and stages of historiography are “erased”. The purpose of this work is to study the internal form and structure of clerical-protective historical research of old believers in the Russian literature of the 1850s: value, spatial, source ‒ study, vector relations of the author to the object of research; a set of concepts that reveal the “mechanism” of explaining old believers; ways to gain knowledge about the split mediated by this structure. The analysis showed that the clerical ideological position expressed in the works of historians of this direction focused on the defense of the “new rite”. It led to a narrowing of the subject of research, limiting it to “opinions” and facts of the statement of schism, which produced the purpose of research ‒ the “exposure” of schismatics and the moral-scholastic method of achieving it and pushed us to use a set of accusatory concepts in explaining the phenomenon under study. It became a barrier to the knowledge of anti-Church protest by the middle of the 19th century. The fact of the practical failure of the clerical doctrine, which was a consequence of its cognitive limitations, was also realized by the bearers of the accusatory tradition themselves. The question of the reasons for the emergence and development of the old believers has become relevant again. A new answer to this question in the late 1850s ‒ early 1860s was given by the historian Afanasiy Prokopyevich Shchapov (1831–1876), who radically changed the theoretical and methodological foundations of the study.
Key words historiography of the old believers, clerical-protective direction, structure of historical research, historiographical fact, direction, stage
Article information
References 1. Crummey, Robert O. The Old Believers and the World of Antichrist: The Vyg Community and Russian State, 1694–1855. Madison: University of Wisconsin Press.1970. (In Engl.) 2. Madzharov, A. S. Formation of the official doctrine of the religious split of the Russian Orthodox Church in the works by V. N. Tatishchev. Irkutsk State University Bulletin, vol. 27, pp. 67–77, 2019. (In Rus.) 3. Molzinsky, V. V. Historiography of the history of old believers in the national culture. Bulletin of Saint Petersburg State University of Culture and Arts. March, no. 1, pp. 29–35, 2017. (In Rus.) 4. Madzharov, A. S. The Doctrine of schism in the Russian Orthodox Church by G. V. Plekhanov and its historiographical sources (N. F. Kapterev, A. P. Shchapov, N. And. Kostomarov, etc.). News of Laboratory of ancient technologies, no. 3, pp. 207–219, 2020. (In Rus.) 5. Borodkin, A. V. A community of believers ‒ Kapitonov Central Russia in the 1650s–1660s. Bulletin of Belgorod, no. 9, pp. 103–108, 2009. (In Rus.) 6. Pokidchenko, M. G. Plekhanov as a historian of socio-economic thought. Historical and economic research, no. 4, pp. 599–612, 2017. (In Rus.) 7. Madzharov, A. S. Applied methodology as a problem of Russian historiography of the XVIII–XIX centuries (problem statement). Humanitarian vector, no. 6, pp. 57–63, 2019. (In Rus.) 8. Ustryalov, N. G. On the system of pragmatic Russian history / View of history as a science. Little-known sources on Russian historiography (the first half of the XIX century). Comp. R. A. Kireeva, K. B. Umbrashko; Institute of Russian history of the Russian Academy of Sciences. M; St. Petersburg: Institute of Russian history of the Russian Academy of Sciences; center for humanitarian initiatives. 2015. (In Rus.) 9. Madzharov, A. S. Afanasy Shchapov. Irkutsk: East Siberian book publishing house, 1992. (In Rus.) 10. Makarii. History of the Russian schism, known as the old believers. St. Petersburg: in the printing house of Korolev and comp., 1855. (In Rus.) 11. Filaret. History of the Russian Church. Kharkiv: University printing house, 1853. (In Rus.) 12. Muravyov, A. N. Schism, denounced by its history. SPb: Printing house of the II Branch of Its own E. I. V. Chancellery,1854. (In Rus.) 13. Ustryalov, N. G. History of the reign of Peter the Great. SPb: Printing house of the II branch of the Sob. His Imp. Led. office, 1858. (In Rus.) 14. Aksakov, I. S. Brief note on the Wanderers or runners. Russian archive, no. 4, pp. 627–643, 1866. (In Rus.) 15. Madzharov, A. S. Afanasy Prokopyevich Shchapov: the history of life (1831–1876) and the life of “History”. Irkutsk: Irkutsk region type No. 1 named After V. M. Posokhin, 2005. (In Rus.)
Full articleClerical-Protective Direction in the Russian Historiography of the Old Believers of the 1850s: the Structure of Historical Research