| Article | |
|---|---|
| Article name | The Problems of the Cossacks’ Essence and Identity in History and Ethnography Research Concepts |
| Authors | Filimonov A.V. External Postgraduate Student, A.V.Filimonov@mail.ru |
| Bibliographic description | Filimonov A. V. The Problems of the Cossacks’ Essence and Identity in History and Ethnography Research Concepts // Humanitarian Vector. 2017. Vol. 12, No. 1. PP. 42–50. |
| Section | Social philosophy |
| UDK | 316.34 (130.2) |
| DOI | |
| Article type | |
| Annotation | The article is devoted to the analysis of the specificity of the problem of the Cossacks’ essence in Russian science. The framework of the intrinsic approach doesn’t allow solving the problem of the Cossacks’ origin due to the fact that a variety of ethnic and class characteristics of different groups of Cossacks as well as the processes of their fast variability do not give a chance to draw any verified conclusions. However, the conducted analysis shows that the scientists have managed to publish a large number of works in which they carry out substantive developments of the problems of the Cossacks ethnic or class origin, presented by autochthonic, migratory and synthetic concepts. The author proves that these concepts cannot offer verified versions concerning communication and continuity between modern Cossacks and those, who are considered their direct historical predecessors, and most often act as spokesmen of someone’s interests. In the conditions of modern processes of arranging the Cossacks in isolation from historical ethnic roots and traditions, substantive theories take a form of mythologemes and are used as justifications of these or those social and political actions, for the sake of integration, or mass population disintegrations represented by the Cossacks. It is important to consider that until now in domestic scientific literature of intrinsic contents, the questions of Cossacks’ identity have been discussed without the structural and constructive concepts, paying attention to the development of group consciousness and placing the emphasis on studying historical deposits of objective knowledge such as knowledge-representation and social myths about the historical past and community genesis. |
| Key words | Cossacks, domestic concepts of ethnos, essence and origin of Cossacks, substantive approach, relative approach, identity of Cossacks, social myths |
| Article information | |
| References | 1. Aktual’nye problemy kazach’ego dvizheniya (kruglyi stol) // Sotsiologicheskie issledovaniya. 1992. № 9. C. 17–29. 2. Barrett T. M. Linii neopredelennosti: severokavkazskii “frontir” Rossii // Amerikanskaya rusistika: vekhi poslednikh let. Imperatorskii period. Samara, 2000. S. 163–194. 3. Belov V. Beloe pokhmel’e: russkaya emigratsiya na rasput’e. M.; Petrograd: Gos. izd-vo, 1923. 155 s. 4. Gareeva D. M. Otechestvennaya istoriografiya kazach’ego zarubezh’ya // Sovremennye problemy literaturovedeniya, lingvistiki, kommunikativistiki glazami molodykh uchenykh. Traditsii i novatorstvo: mezhvuzovskii sb. Ufa: BashGU, 2015. 181 s. 5. Gordeev A. A. Istoriya kazakov. M.: Strastnoi bul’var, 1992. 640 s. 6. Dulimov E. I. Stanovlenie i involyutsiya gosudarstvennykh form organizatsii kazachestva v pravovom prostranstve Rossiiskogo gosudarstva v XVI–XX vv.: avtoref. dis. … d-ra yurid. nauk: 12.00.01. Saratov, 2003. 51 s. 7. Zhukov A. V., Peshkov I. G. Zabaikal’skie kazaki i ikh potomki. Chita: ZabGU, 2014. 174 s. 8. Karamzin N. M. Istoriya gosudarstva Rossiiskogo. SPb.: Izd. Meditsinskoi tip. (Voennoi tip. Glavnogo shtaba Ego Imperatorskogo velichestva), 1817. T. 5. 592 s. 9. Kiblitskii A. A. Politicheskaya samoidentifikatsiya donskogo kazachestva: tekhnologicheskii aspekt: dis. ... kand. polit. nauk: 23.00.02. Rostov-na-Donu, 2007. 162 s. 10. Klyuchevskii V. O. Sochineniya v devyati tomakh. T. 2. M.: Mysl’, 1957. 448 s. 11. Kolupaev D. V. Sibirskoe kazachestvo vo vtoroi polovine XIX veka ‒ 1850–1900 gg.: sotsial’no-ekonomicheskoe razvitie: avtoref. dis. … d-ra ist. nauk: 07.00.02. Irkutsk, 2011. 34 s. 12. Korenyako V. A. Kazachestvo v Stavropol’skom krae ‒ faktor stabilizatsii ili konfliktogeneza // Vozrozhdenie kazachestva: nadezhdy i opaseniya. M., 1998. S. 104–138. 13. Krasil’nikov A. Krakh nordicheskoi teorii proiskhozhdeniya ariev. Kazaki – kto oni? [Elektronnyi resurs]. Rezhim dostupa: http://www.km.ru/science-tech/2013/12/30/ (data obrashcheniya: 25.11.2016). 14. Kuzeev R. G., Babenko V. Ya. Etnograficheskie i etnicheskie gruppy (k probleme geterogennosti etnosa) // Etnos i ego podrazdeleniya. M., 1992. Ch. 1. S. 17–37. 15. Mavrodin V. V. Slavyano-russkoe naselenie Nizhnego Dona i Severnogo Kavkaza v X–XIV vekakh // Uchenye zapiski LGPI im. A. I. Gertsena. 1938. T. 11. S. 231–234. 16. Mamonov V. F. Istoriya kazachestva Rossii. Ekaterinburg; Chelyabinsk: In-t gumanitarnykh issledovanii, 1995. T. 1. 237 s. 17. Markedonov S. M. Zakoldovannoe slovo // Rodina. 2004. № 5. S. 93–96. 18. Matveev O. V. Yavlenie kazachestva v istorii i kul’ture Rossii // Ocherki traditsionnoi kul’tury kazachestv Rossii. M.; Krasnodar, 2002. S. 10–44. 19. Meshcheryakov N. L. Na perelome (iz nastroenii belogvardeiskoi emigratsii). M., 1922. 73 s. 20. Murad Adzhi. Aziatskaya Evropa. M.: AST, 2008. 1128 s. 21. Perevalov S. M. Vosstanie diletantov: rossiiskaya istoriografiya na rubezhe vekov // Vestn. Vladikavkazskogo nauch. tsentra. 2002. № 3. S. 6–7. 22. Popov A. Istoriya o Donskom Voiske. Khar’kov: Tip. un-ta, 1814. Kn. 1. 761 s. 23. Prokop’ev V. B. K voprosu o proiskhozhdenii kazachestva i poyavlenii pervykh kazakov v Zabaikal’e // Vestn. Buryatskogo un-ta, 2010. № 2. S. 112–116. 24. Pushkin A. S. Istoriya Pugacheva. M.: Krasand, 2014. 156 s. 25. Ryblova M. A. Kazaki vozvrashchayutsya: istoriya i sud’ba odnoi nauchnoi teorii // Kazachestvo: proshloe i nastoyashchee. Rostov-na-Donu: YuNTs RAN, 2010. Vyp. 3. S. 278–285. 26. Savel’ev E. P. Kazaki. Istoriya. Vladikavkaz: SPAS, 1991. 442 s. S. 282–299. 27. Sen’ D. V. Kazachestvo Dona i Severo-Zapadnogo Kavkaza v otnosheniyakh s musul’manskimi gosudarstvami Prichernomor’ya (vtoraya polovina XVII ‒ nachalo XVIII v.): avtoref. dis. ... d-ra ist. nauk: 07.00.02. Rostov-na-Donu, 2009. 54 s. 28. Sopov A. V. Sovremennye nauchnye teorii proiskhozhdeniya kazachestva [Elektronnyi resurs]. Rezhim dostupa: http://www.cyberleninka.ru/article/n/sovremennye-nauchnye-kontseptsii-proishozhdeniya-kazachestva (data obrashcheniya: 20.11.2016). 29. Tabolina T. Osnovnye napravleniya izucheniya kazachestva [Elektronnyi resurs]. Rezhim dostupa: http:// www.cbs1vao.ru/kazak/024_osn_napr.htm (data obrashcheniya: 25.11.2016). 30. Shatilo I. S. Spornye voprosy identifikatsii kazach’ego dvizheniya // Vlast’. 2015. № 6. S. 46–52. |
| Full article | The Problems of the Cossacks’ Essence and Identity in History and Ethnography Research Concepts |
| 0 | |
| 15 | |
